RRio
Well Shucks. Ima Luddite. No, really, it's true. Luddite thru and thru. I don't care if my brass is Brite and Shiny. I also don't really subscribe to many of the concoctions folks dump in their media in search of "like new." There. See. Luddite.
First understanding I shoot APP (BP Sub for those whom live under rocks) and after shooting, I rinse the brass in Warm Water and White Vinegar. After drying (small oven) I dump about a cap full of Dillon Case Polish (if I remember) in with the Lizard Litter (Walnut Shell) and then tumble, essentially dry for about an hour. DONE.
Shiny is not necessary for loading and shooting. Shiny is only an issue for those suffering a form of OCD about brass looking "Like New." Clean is necessary. Anything after Clean is "Cake." Oh, and some stains on yer brass lets folks know you really do shoot alot. Burma Shave
Hide and Watch
Ah My Dear Coffin!
the wealth of sources for off-topic comments you provided is too good to pass up!
Firstly, and on topic, I agree, "shiny is not necessary" and "clean is good enough".
Green is bad, Clean is good, a little tarnish is ok (watch for weak spots and cracks).
technically and metallurgically, cleaning TOO well does actually thin the brass minutely each time.
and theoretically, a thin layer of normal dull brass oxidation may help in terms of longevity (note the patina on brass frame guns)
Off Topic-
Heavenly Carbuncles! Coffinmaker Admits to Shooting Cartridges!
Coffinmaker The Luddite
- Do you have the appropriate Wooden Shoes ( Sabots ) ?
Have you ever kicked them into moving machinery ( Sabo-tage ) ?
yhs
and amateur historian
who often gets it wrong anyway
prof marvel