My preferences in firearms tend to run to "plain" side of things, although I do like fancy wood. And I'm rather a perfectionist. Yes, I would choose USFA over any other.
Actually, I already have most of what I really want from USFA. My "ultimate," ordered and delivered in 2008, is a black powder framed .44/40 ("Frontier Six Shooter"), 7.5-inch barrel, fancy one-piece European walnut grip, and standard blue (with color case hardening as well of course, including hammer). The only change I would make if I could order it now would be that I would want the higher-end blue, which I believe was the "Armory Blue." I was short of cash at the time, and I couldn't justify the extra cost, or at least that was my reasoning at the time. GaryG may remember my special order (as I was probably a troublesome customer) and his shipping it to Havre, MT.
Now, if I could order another revolver from USFA, I would like to have essentially the same configuration with a 4.75-inch barrel. Not because I dislike the 7.5-inch barrel, which is my favorite for shooting, but because the 4.75-inch is so much easier to pack about and provides sufficient accuracy. I have both lengths in .45 Colt in both USFA and 2nd Generation Colt revolvers, and like them all for different reasons.