AH My Dear Paladin -
What to Do? Why, pack up all your worldly goods and relocate to New Mexico, Texas, Arizona ....
ah but wait I should have read your post first......
5 inches. Most definitely 5 inches.
I cut a pair of 1851's to 5 inches.
I am cutting some Remmies to 5 inches.
and I am cutting a spare 1860 barrel to 5 inches (I already did a "long snubnose" at 3 inches)
I guess my two most favorite barrel lengths in revolvers are 3" snubbies and 5" belt pistols.
I have always been amazed that the "standard" service length in cartridge guns has become 4", and "standard" snubbies are ~ 2"
and I always felt that the 4.75" SAA was very nearly perfect ....
yhs
prof marvel