MD.
this post is NOT a criticism of you, so please don't take it that way, it is just an observation about
rifles that I have noticed over the past couple years since I have gotten into the sport and my thouights
about that particular rifle only, don't read anything into my post here other than it's my thoughts about
that gun
there is a reason why that rifle is for sale. It is one of the "mistake guns" that I posted about
over on the Shiloh board and others jumped in and agreed with my reasoning. When you
read down through the text you see:
This rifle is chambered for the large .50-90 (2-1/2") Sharps straight case.
then a litte further down:
Trigger reach is 13-3/4". Weight is 10.9 pounds
With a weight of 10.9 lbs, and chambered in 50-90, if you shot that thing with the size bullets
needed for target work (most of the people I know shoot 650 to 700 gr bullets in their 50-90's)
you might need some cortisone shots in your shoulder and definitely would end up with a
recoil headache.
As for it being a hunting gun, possibly, but 10.9 lbs is still a bit heavy to carry around too much
and a 32" barrel a bit long for the woods, it would work for carrying out and shooting from a
stand off sticks.
A little further down the list there at TOTW is a Shiloh 50-90. It weighs in at 12.3 lbs. That is a bit
better weight.
My shooting partner shot our other friend's 50-90. It is a 34" heavy barreled Sharps, so it weighs a bit
over 12.3 (I don't know what the extra 2" of barrel would add"). My friend is an experienced 45-110
shooter, but when he shot the 50-90, he said he knew he shot something.
I have gotten recoil headaches from my 45-100's before, and even a 45-90 with the stiff loads I use
and a 540 gr bullet can get your attention if not held correctly. My 90 is a heavy barreled Sharps.
I let one of my 100's using a 540 gr bullet get a run at my collar bone ONCE. notice I said ONCE. I can't
imagine a light weight 50-90. I turned down the opportunity to shoot our friends.
My new 45-110 weighs a published 13.5 lbs and my other 110 weighs almost 15 lbs. It is not a hunting
gun to say the least, but sure tames down the recoil.
That rifle could be made into a shooter if a mercury recoil reducer was installed into the stock, maybe
2 of them would be better however, it doesn't say what the barrel's rate of twist is. That could be
another issue.
Some of the tip offs that will help indicate a "mistake gun" are phrases like "only shot 10 times", looks
"brand new and barely fired", "owner is motivated to sell". prices lower than what they should be to
buy the rifle new, as the American made (and Pedersoli's somewhat) hold their value without
depreciation, etc etc etc. If you watch the auction sites, there are usually 2 catergories of these
single shot rifles that turn up"
1. the mistake guns and they are pretty obvious
2. the guns that someone is trying to make a big profit on due to the waiting periods to get a decent
one. they are trying to capitalize on a "I want it". Usually Shilohs, these will be inflated 4 to 500.00 over
what it really should cost.
Right now, over on gunbroker, is a guy trying to sell a bunch of C. Sharps rifles that are in some of the
weirdest combinations of features.
The C. Sharps 1875 make a decent gun at a pretty decent price. I have some friends that shoot them
and saw other folks out at Alliance doing well with theirs.
Best regards and a tip of the hat for taking the time to point the rifle out.
Dave C.