I've recently been in touch with a sculptor-artist who lives in Kansas who has a keen interest in as well as considerable knowledge of the Buffalo Hunters. (He certainly lives in the right area for this)
In fact he's shot several Buffalo himself as well as accompanying other hunters on a total of
31 big ranch Buffalo Hunts.
Discussing this with him, the topic of the Buffalo Skinners and what knives they used came up.
He told me that the favorite knife of the period was a rather plain set of knives made in Sheffield England by the John Wilson Knife Co. Their knives were marketed under the name "I. Wilson".
He said there were certainly many other knife makers, including several others from Sheffield, but for those who knew what they were doing (and depended upon the best steel and sharp blades) they pretty much sought out the I. Wilson brand.
He has a number of these old I. Wilson knives and says he's taken them along on several of these Buffalo hunts where wealthy hunters have brought along custom made Skinning knives costing several hundred dollars apiece. He said when all was said and done, they all came away in awe of how well these very plain, utilitarian old knives worked.
I made up this shadow box to put on display along a wall where I have big game prints, including one of a pair of Buffalo Runners up on a rise one of them shooting his big Sharps on his cross sticks while the other scouts and points out the next shot.
These were the knives that got the job done.