One thing you could check on when you make the chamber cast. There were in fact, two ".43 Spanish" cartridges. The one most people refer to is the necked version, nearly identical to the .44-77 Remington, only it was loaded with a .439" bullet. It is described in Venturino's "Shooting Buffalo Rifles of the Old West", in the section on the .44-77. The other is the ".43 Spanish Reformado", which was used by the Spanish in the Span-Am War. These are a sort of tapered case (not much shoulder to speak of), that is loaded with a .446" bullet. The military round for this was loaded with a brass-jacketed bullet which often corroded and turned green in the tropics of Cuba and the Philippines, causing many to label them as "poisoned bullets", which I suppose they were, tho not intentionally. Both cases can obtained from Buffalo Arms, and are formed from .348 Win. brass The Reformado reloading dies are only made by 4-D (also available from Buffalo Arms), and a little pricier than the "common" .43 Spanish, which Lee carries. Make sure you slug the bore as well as making the chamber cast. My Reformado shoots pretty decent, about 2"-2 1/2" at 100 yards.