Yes it should slip in and out easily, you don't want to tug or have to use your off hand to hold the holster down..
that said, it should also be deep enough to house the revolver...so when you move it won't fall out..
That is a big bad DQ.
I'd suggest you view the leather forum here, there are several makers with great talent posting there.
Cliff Findley comes to mind... Ray Hanchett aka " Bluesman " , Homer Brown , David Carrico ,
Tommy Tornado, Marshal Will Wingam are some others...
I can't list them all
but the talent there is TOP Drawer...
If you want it to look like it was there, used , and back...the real deal ... Chuck Burrows
If your look for more of a competition rig ..maybe Red Cent
and if it unique or exotic look at.. Kid Tarico