OK I just couldnt stand it anymore. Took both of them out and fired them with my loads. 200 gr rnfp from a lyman mold, lyman alox 5.5 grains tite group. Shot well. One right on point of aim point of impact. the other a tad high and to the left. I'll lighten the load, it did seam a tad heavy.
But you know something,,,,, I really like the 44-40 cartridge. I know lots of folks have had problems with loading them, but it works well with me. The thing I was impressed about it, there was no blowby, the empties came out as clean as they went in, well on the outside, and the pistols cleaned up well.
Dang, now I got to get me a rifle in 44-40...............