Hi - I'd originally posted this over on Coltforums but they sent me here because my pistol is a clone. I'm just gonna copy the post, though. Call me lazy.
I have a 1970s Armi Jager Dakota, .357 cal, that I got from my uncle (although it once belonged to my grandfather as well). It is a SAA clone that appears to be part-for-part quite similar to the "real" thing, so I'm hoping the same knowledge applies.
The lock up on this gun has always been very tight but several months ago it developed rotational play, to where the cylinder would not catch when the hammer was cocked all the way back. It was as if it was overshooting the locking bit deal (that is a technical term). If you turned it either way with your hand it would click in place and lock up fine. This problem got worse and worse until one day the pawl snapped and the entire gun stopped working, complete loss of spring tension in the whole mechanism... so I sent it to a gunsmith who is a personal friend of a friend and had it repaired for fairly cheap. My guess was that the pawl had become worn and was responsible for the play - but now with a new pawl the cylinder is still doing the thing, so in fact I think it was the cylinder which broke the original pawl.
The finish around the notches is quite worn so I'm not sure if that is a sign that the timing is off or if that's natural with these guns. Additionally, the ridges the pawl interacts with seem 'peened' or worn away. The gun is fairly old and was run very hard in its past life as a quick-draw gun, so I wouldn't be shocked if it needs a complete rebuild.
Here's a picture of the cylinder.
If it needs to be worked on - is it work I can do myself or should I definitely see to it that it's received by a specialist? If it's the latter, this gun will be out of commission for some time, which is an awful shame because it's so much fun to shoot, but I can't afford another trip to the gun doctor when I've got a Mauser C96 on the way.
Thanks!