I thought I'd ask this on the Colt forum. I know the difference between the bp frame and the cross pin. Do any of you guys feel that using a cross pin Colt, for an earlier time, is a terrible historic sin ?...
No other issues. Just curious if the more 'hard core' folks would pass a good revolver up just because it was cross pin instead of bp frame.
That's a great question. I try to fall into the hardcore category with my authenticity but I do it for a personal sense of achievement in this hobby and not to look down on others. (Why look down on someone because I am more into playing dress up on a museum-quality level than they are?) Since I have a belief that "to each, their own" philosophy, I get along pretty well with those who could care less about authenticity. I am more concerned with safety and common sense. (end of disclaimer) In regards to historic authenticity down to the smallest possible details, my answer is yes, a BP frame should be used. If you are doing vaudevillian-esque stunt shows to entertain the public or if you are doing shooting competition, I really don't see the harm in using a cross pin. The 73 SAA design is a good and reliable one and I use it just about as much in modern shooting as I do in living history. I think the decision on this is really dictated by the individual's desire to really get into seeing how close he/she can get to simulating another time period versus someone simply enjoying what they currently have.I'm interested in hearing how other people feel about this too.-Dave