44-40 Navy Arms Schofield with Black Powder

Started by Junkbug, October 09, 2026, 07:26:05 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Junkbug

Greetings all. Has anyone here run Black Powder in their Uberti Schofields? I have one in 44-40. I know fouling is a problem. If nothing else, I put Crisco over the cylinder mouths, just like a cap and ball revolver

I am wondering if full Black Powder loads will prematurely wear out the latching mechanism. This is truly the guns weak point. Does anyone have insight on this?

Thanks

Cap'n Redneck

I've had two Uberti Schofields chambered in .45 Colt.
I loaded and fired .45 Schofield cartridges in them.
(Around 25 grains of blackpowder and a 250 grain lead bullet w/ homemade blackpowder lube)
The early production one was quite loose in the cylinder arbor (had a lot of play) and would work tolerably for a couple of cylinders.
The later production one was tight and would seize up after one cylinder.
I ended up selling them on, and invested in a couple of Uberti 1872 Open-Tops in .45 Schofield instead.  They are much better suited for blackpowder loads.

I have recently acquired an Uberti S&W #3 Russian in .44 Russian, and with a reduced load of around 18 grains of Swiss # 3 blackpowder (2Fg), sesame seeds as a filler and a 200 grain lead bullet w/ homemade blackpowder lube it will actually run fine for several cylinders.

My main application for these guns have been precision target shooting at 25 yards and CAS-shooting.

I will highly recommend trying out sesame seeds as a filler in reduced loads for your .44-40 loads.  The seeds will release oil under combustion/compression and lube the bore and cylinder arbor between shots. 

You also have the option of using .44 Russian cartridges in your .44-40 chambered Schofield.

I have fired .44 Russian BP cartridges from my .44-40 chambered Uberti 1860 Henry rifle, and the empty cases would chamber effortlessly in the .44 Russian chambers of the # 3 Russian revolver afterwards.

"As long as there's lead in the air, there's still hope..."
Frontiersman & Frontiersman Gunfighter: The only two categories where you can play with your balls and shoot your wad while tweaking the nipples on a pair of 44s.

Junkbug

Thanks for the insights. I never heard about sesame seeds as a case filler. I will try that. I also may have some .44 Russian brass laying around. I'll try that also.

You have kind of confirmed my suspicion that full black powder loads out of these replicas in cases that will hold 35 grains is probably not the best idea. Mostly I am worried about damaging the latch, which may not be practical to repair if damaged.


Coffinmaker


 :) Junkbug,

The biggest problem inherent in the reproduction Schofields is the lack of a suitable bushing between the cylinder face and frame.  With Black Powder the guns simply foul out rapidly.

I can't address latch damage by a steady diet of full loads as I don't know anyone who has/had done it.  The fouling is bad enough most shooters quit BP before they could get that far.

wildman1

Quote from: Junkbug on October 09, 2026, 07:26:05 AMGreetings all. Has anyone here run Black Powder in their Uberti Schofields? I have one in 44-40. I know fouling is a problem. If nothing else, I put Crisco over the cylinder mouths, just like a cap and ball revolver

I am wondering if full Black Powder loads will prematurely wear out the latching mechanism. This is truly the guns weak point. Does anyone have insight on this?

Thanks
The lube in the front of the cylinder is a great idea, I dip my cartridges in lube before I put them in the cylinder on revolvers that will foul out quickly without it.
 Works great and makes cleanup really easy.
wM1
WARTHOG, Dirty Rat #600, BOLD #1056, CGCS,GCSAA, NMLRA, NRA, AF&AM, CBBRC.  If all that cowboy has ever seen is a stockdam, he ain't gonna believe ya when ya tell him about whales.