My Dear Coffin and Capt Q
Oh Coffin, thou art not a killjoy, you are in fact a conversationalist (like myself) .
And better to
dicker bicker fight converse about differences in prefences than about politics,
because it is not good for one to blow ones stack and .... I see Mrs Marvel cocking the dart gun....
I myself use the phrase "historically accurate" only if making the point when I am at an event/place based on a specific time period-such as
a strictish Rondy, a sponsered museum event, or a specific re-enactment event, such as one of the special events at Bents Old Fort,
one of the events at El Rancho de las Golondrinas (a Living History Museum near Santa Fe) or when I was a volunteer slave worker
blacksmith assistance docent at Fort Snelling ( 1812) and Gibbs Farm (1870) ...
At such times, we are attempting to educate the great unwashed public and convey actual facts and display and correctly use reproductions of
actual artifacts , and dress in the manner appropiate to the time ... I enjoy being a Docent/Instructor and babbling at people and comparing
history notes...
It is great fun, but also a lot of effort. IAnd when doing it I AM in a tipi, or an 1870's one-pole pyramid, and use candles & tinware & etc...
but it IS pretend, and the car and modern everything is just a few hundred yards away...
I myself several different goals in mind - and historicity is only one game of many....
I like the oldy HB 250ish gr .45 Colt bullet just because it was so ubiquitous and versatile, and I love pulling one out of a vest
pocket at a museum or event to show to the
rubes tourists citizens what one looks and feels like and expound at length on the topic
Then I can pull a Brown Bess Musket ball out of onther vest pocket and play "compare and contrast" .... and then pull out a 45-90 buffalo cartridge...
I llike the Big Lubes BECAUSE of the Modernity - explicitly cuz they carry a ton o' lube for when i use BP. The .45's even work remarkably well in my .45 Underhammer .
I did not go lighter than the 200 gr Big Lube just cuz "too stubby" starts to loose accuracy at further distances - the old 45-70 "collar button"
never worked well for me....
If I need a really light load I use roundballs! lightly crimped, a light BP or smokeless load makes for a true powder puff wimp load!
Then I am playing with Heavy For Caliber bullets for specific reasons centered around the old Brit Webly manstoppers ... been watching Zulu & etc too much...
heavy bullet, lighter load... heavy and slow ....
" Get Down Eden"
https://www.youtube.com/embed/q2iKrEwQuJc-----------
My Good Green
the problem is, Dixie only makes wordy statements, no facts backed up by numbers....
so we don't really know exactly what diameter bullets it drops, until they tell us.
I will have to go cast & measure some big lubes and report back on their diameter...
yhs
prof marvel
postscript:
I'm on the road. Bored. Feeling some Contrary and Neglected. No insult intended. Except for those two Teeth Grinding Terms.
I am on the sofa and comfortable and contrary. no offense taken, it's all just a game & fun. even the docent
crap stuff.