Thank you. I tried everything I knew to do. Including something similar (but it wasn't brass). I was afraid if I kept poking around in that chamber with stuff I'd end up scratching up the gun and I sure didn't want to do that.
Anyway, it still bothers me that this happened at all. I'm still wondering what exactly I did wrong to cause this. The powder weight in the load was on the low end. It is possible to shoot a.429 240 gr JHP bullet through a .429 bore even if it is at a slow velocity. The only thing I can think is that the cartridge was worn out after times being used. One thing is clear: It wasn't the gun that failed, it was the cartridge that failed. But people have shot much hotter loads than that in .44-40 out of 1892 actions.
I'm not going to try this again because I don't know what went wrong. For now, just stick to lead 200 gr hardcast bullets. Should be adequate for what the gun is and anything I'll be shooting at paper or flesh
Hey, if you did all you were comfortable doing, then that was enough. We all have our limits as to how far we'll dig into things. I'll R&R a barrel on a toggle link action, but won't even attempt soldering. Anyhow...
Your load was very reasonable. Who knows why the case separated? Case separation is not at all an uncommon occurrence. Could've been, or be headspace that's a little on the long side, a case that was ready to separate regardless, or a combination of the two.
CHT