Cas City Forum Hall & CAS-L

Special Interests - Groups & Societies => The Barracks => Topic started by: Cedar County Sheriff on July 27, 2006, 08:55:54 am

Title: Stars of Merit
Post by: Cedar County Sheriff on July 27, 2006, 08:55:54 am
Gentlemen;
  I was recently honored at the SASS Northwest Regional Costume contest as Best Dressed Military, and was wondering if Capt. Barrett is still the issueing autority for the Star of Merit?

 If he is not, then to whom do I contact?

 I await further instruction.

Lt. Col. Douglas Cedar, US Cav.
Commanding Officer
Division of the Pacific Northwest
Dept. of the Pacific
GAF

aka
Title: Re: Stars of Merit
Post by: US Scout on July 27, 2006, 10:56:50 am
Bvt Lt Col Cedar County Sheriff, you are hearby awarded the Star of Merit for winning the Best Dressed Military at the SASS Northwest Regional.  WELL DONE on your accomplishment.  Please let us know what the uniform was.

Captain Barrett, like Missouri Scotsman, has retired from his duties.

For now, I am the issuing authority for Stars of Merit.  If anyone believes they have earned one over the last year or so, contact me and I'll confirm the award if appropriate.

Bvt Col Bull Schmitt is working on updating and reactivating the website so the SOM can be requested on-line (as can enlistments).  We'll announce when that capability is activated.

Most recently, Chantilly earned a Star of Merit for the Mini-Muster, and Bvt Lt Col and Major Matt Lewis has earned one for his victory at End of Trail this year, as well as cleaning a match in uniform.  Sgt Drydock earned one last year at the SASS Convention for best dressed Military. 

I know there are some others, including some who have promoted the GAF at living history events or reenactments.  Please let me know so I can begin to update our records.  Basically, if you believed you earned one and never saw it posted on the website, send me the information.

US Scout
GAF Commanding

Title: Re: Stars of Merit
Post by: Major Matt Lewis on July 28, 2006, 12:05:24 pm
Well,

To my account, all and all, I would have 5 Stars of Merit, The Commanders Citation for the First GAF Muster and a Veterans Award.  All in All, if I had a GAF Medal (Cough Cough) than it would look pretty sharp  :o  NOW, something to consider, since we award medals for the Muster, that I believe have been authorized to wear with devices, than if we have a Muster Medal, do we still rate The Star of Merit, or would they be considered redundant awards?   ???

Riddle me that Batman.....  ;)
Title: Re: Stars of Merit
Post by: Cedar County Sheriff on July 28, 2006, 05:19:38 pm
Gentlemen;
  The Persona Col. Douglas Cedar, is a full Colonel, US Cavalry, circa 1879, as a graduate of the Military academy class of '58, I was a junior officer during the CW. At the end of the war, I remained in service and was sent west. With 25 years' service, I have worked hard to attain my present rank. The uniform was Full Dress Blue. If I can acquire photos from some of the folk that were there, I will try to forward them.

Your Humble Servant,

Lt. Col. Douglas Cedar, US Cav.
Commanding Officer
Div. of the Pacific Northwest
Dept. of the Pacific
GAF

aka
Title: Re: Stars of Merit
Post by: US Scout on July 29, 2006, 05:51:16 am
NOW, something to consider, since we award medals for the Muster, that I believe have been authorized to wear with devices, than if we have a Muster Medal, do we still rate The Star of Merit, or would they be considered redundant awards?   ???


An excellent question and one that I have pondered a satisfactory answer to for some time.

When the GAF first started, no one envisioned having a need to wear more than the GAF organizational medal, thus any awards earned were to be represented by stars, oak leaves or the veteran's "V". 

That concept worked pretty well until you came up with the idea of presenting medals to winners at the Muster, which are also authorized to be worn on the uniform.  I like the idea, as you know, so no complaints from me, even though it did complicate the GAF award system a bit.  In fact, I requested Kayleen continue the tradition at this year's muster but she hasn't informed me that she will do so.

These Muster award medals are equivilent to a Star of Merit (winning a match in your category, winning the uniform competition, etc), thus potentially duplicating a Star of Merit award on the GAF medal.

I see two options open to us (and I recognize that there are several more possibilities).  Bear in mind that one of the things we want to avoid is too many medals being worn on our uniform and thus looking like a Russian general. 

The first is that medals awarded at the Musters are treated as separate awards, but which will not be duplicated by a star on the GAF Medal.  In other words, if someone wins a medal at the Musters, they wear that medal in addition to the GAF Medal, but do not place a new star on the GAF medal.  This would require that only blue (1st place), red (2nd place) and white (3rd place) ribboned medals be given out at the Musters.  Subsequent Muster awards would be displayed on these medals. 

For example, at the first Muster I received 1st place in the uniform competion and at the second Muster I received 3rd place in my shooting category.  I would wear a blue ribboned medal and white ribboned medal in addition to my GAF medal.  If I were to win a 1st place at another Muster, I could place a star on my blue ribboned medal.  If I were to win 2nd place, I could add a red-ribboned medal.  I would not add any additional stars to my GAF Medal for awards received at a Muster.

The second option is that the wearer has the option of wearing all Stars of Merit on the GAF medal.  This could cause some crowding of devices eventually but would permit wearing just one medal on the uniform to maintain the Victorian-era look where few medals were actually worn.

US Scout
GAF, Commanding

Title: Re: Stars of Merit
Post by: Major Matt Lewis on July 29, 2006, 08:29:31 am


That concept worked pretty well until you came up with the idea of presenting medals to winners at the Muster, which are also authorized to be worn on the uniform.  I like the idea, as you know, so no complaints from me, even though it did complicate the GAF award system a bit.  In fact, I requested Kayleen continue the tradition at this year's muster but she hasn't informed me that she will do so.

These Muster award medals are equivilent to a Star of Merit (winning a match in your category, winning the uniform competition, etc), thus potentially duplicating a Star of Merit award on the GAF medal.

I see two options open to us (and I recognize that there are several more possibilities).  Bear in mind that one of the things we want to avoid is too many medals being worn on our uniform and thus looking like a Russian general. 

The first is that medals awarded at the Musters are treated as separate awards, but which will not be duplicated by a star on the GAF Medal.  In other words, if someone wins a medal at the Musters, they wear that medal in addition to the GAF Medal, but do not place a new star on the GAF medal.  This would require that only blue (1st place), red (2nd place) and white (3rd place) ribboned medals be given out at the Musters.  Subsequent Muster awards would be displayed on these medals. 

For example, at the first Muster I received 1st place in the uniform competion and at the second Muster I received 3rd place in my shooting category.  I would wear a blue ribboned medal and white ribboned medal in addition to my GAF medal.  If I were to win a 1st place at another Muster, I could place a star on my blue ribboned medal.  If I were to win 2nd place, I could add a red-ribboned medal.  I would not add any additional stars to my GAF Medal for awards received at a Muster.

The second option is that the wearer has the option of wearing all Stars of Merit on the GAF medal.  This could cause some crowding of devices eventually but would permit wearing just one medal on the uniform to maintain the Victorian-era look where few medals were actually worn.

US Scout
GAF, Commanding




Yes,

I do acknowledge that this is inherently my fault... ;) ;D  and as you know, I like the idea of wearing additional devices on the GAF Medals to avoid the "Soviet General" effect.  I also like in theory the idea of not "junking" up the GAF Medal.  I think keeping it to SOM's for Non-Muster Events and the Veterans Award and Commanders Citation would be great.  We have never had an official ruling, so may we consider this one?
Title: Re: Stars of Merit
Post by: US Scout on July 30, 2006, 06:28:52 am
Pending mutiny in the ranks, consider it official. 

To designate the distinctiion of a Muster award over other Stars of Merit, a Medal (Star of Merit) earned at a Muster will be worn as a separate device (blue, red or white medal).  All other Stars of Merit earned for competion, presenting a lecture, etc, will be worn on the GAF Medal (and yes, we're working on that issue, too).

US Scout
GAF, Commanding
Title: Re: Stars of Merit
Post by: Major Matt Lewis on July 30, 2006, 05:25:10 pm
Sounds like a winner....
Title: Re: Stars of Merit
Post by: Steel Horse Bailey on August 10, 2006, 01:20:46 pm
I think my Star request got lost during the time Cpt . Barrett was taking his new job.

I placed first (in uniform) in the Black Powder Duelist Category last Oct. at the 2005 NCOWS Eastern Regional.  Does that qualify me?
I also placed LAST in this year's NCOWS National, (rifle trouble  ::) ) but I don't think this one counts ... :)
Title: Re: Stars of Merit
Post by: River City John on August 10, 2006, 07:28:24 pm
I think they cancel each other out, Steel Horse. ::) ;D
Title: Re: Stars of Merit
Post by: Gripmaker on August 12, 2006, 10:42:43 pm
I have won Best Dressed at the NCOWS Convention and the 2006 Iowa State Championships. Not too worried about what this entitles me to but I am curious what the award for Veteran is. Can someone please explain this?
Title: Re: Stars of Merit
Post by: Pitspitr on August 13, 2006, 08:05:31 am
From the GAF web site:

"The GAF shall also recognize Veteran status through the Veteran's Award. The Veteran's Award will be a "V" device attached to the ribbon of the GAF Medal beneath any Stars of Merit. The criteria for this Award is as follows:
Be on Active Duty currently, OR
Served at least one enlistment on Active Duty, OR
Served at least two enlistments in a Reserve Component, OR
Have at least one Tour of Duty in Combat
A Soldier will need to purchase their Veteran's Award. This Award should be available at any local military surplus store or online"