I wouldn't use much, but perhaps some canning wax (paraffein [sp?]) will firm it up. I started a mix with 1/4 lb. par. wax, 1/4 lb beeswax and 2 cups of olive oil. It was too stiff for my hand luber, but would have been OK for pan lubing. I tried to soften it enough for my C&B hand luber (much like a cake decorator) and after nearly a full quart of olive oil, it's OK - but you really have to be pushing on it to work! It, like yours, seems to soften up when moved either with a finger or mechanically, but for C&B that's a plus. I don't have a lube/sizer, so I can't say how it would work in them.