Yeah, that last group is definitely better. Before I got into CAS I was working up loads with mostly 240gr SWC and RNFP (I don't cast), and I never got what I thought was a particularly accurate load, but "good enough for CAS" and all my shooting time now is spent at matches, no "practice" or working up loads (mostly 180gr and 200gr now for less recoil). That's okay with me.
I don't think anyone is mad. Some folks is just kinda opinionated
I personally don't think a 3rd Gen Colt, especially one that is not a .45, will be particularly collectible for a long time. Most prospective buyers will be shooters, and an action job by someone they've heard of probably won't detract from the value even if it doesn't add to it, either.