Okay, I am presuming you are talkin modern replicas, so that is how I can answer. Two Schofields comparing to 2 Opentops, four Uberti SAAs and a genuine Colt Bisley, I think that the Schofields are possessors of good crisp triggers. The Ubertis have good triggers, 3 of the 4 being very crisp but heavy. The Colt puts them all to shame, but it is a Bisley, made when Colts were the target standard of the world. So I would try the S&W, see how you like the grip, it is more of an adjustment than the trigger to me.