Thanks for the details and information. My Remington measurements are as follows.
Cylinder length 1.997"
Inside frame length 2.034"
current shim 0.029"
(theoretical)endplay 0.006"
pin diameter 0.266"
bolt notch 0.148"
cylinder diameter 1.624"
It seems that the Pietta-sized conversion would work for length, probably need the Pietta pin and ream my frame out a bit. The original pin is gone and has been oversize-reamed already. My concern for timing is in the the bolt notch diameter, possibly need to set the original aside and fit a reproduction one, sized to lock-up tightly? It will be interesting. As an aside, any preferences regarding conversion cylinders? I like the Pale Rider appearance, is it "real world useful" however? Again, thanks for your detailed answers and generous sharing of information and experience.
Also, yes I am sharing and loitering on the Remington site, more activity there, I enjoy the banter and interaction. And as an aside, I loaded up 40 of the J and D conicals with Goex FFFg last night, interested to get out in the woods this next week and see how real blackpowder sounds/feels/smells!
I myself would save the original parts then start with a cheap Pietta cylinder, and modify a replacement cylinder bolt
(and the existing bolt window if necessary) to fit. If one had to tighten up the barrel/cylinder gap one "ought to" be able to readily remove the barrel and turn the barrel shoulder down a hair. As you said, The Pietta pin should be easy/peasy.
Once you managed that it should be simplicity itself to swap in/out a Pietta conversion cylinder.
BTW, you might want to look up "Racing" - he is a fellow over in sweden who has been restoring/refurbishing/modifying original 1858's which can be obtained completely license free over there , and he is crazy good with a lathe, bridgeport, and TIG.
my preference for conversion cylinders....
well my first set of 2 were two 5 shot Kirsts, cylinders only, and I created my own "thick plate" backplates. I like these a lot
because they drop in/out easily, and emulate the early "thich-plate conversions) that allow use of percussion cylinder, and still
allow quick reloads "on the gun" as well. I am also playing with a ported thick plate that looks somewhat like a frankenstein colt thuer conversion
my second set were two 5 shot Kirst gated conversions, which I making into a permanent "period conversion".
then I started acquiring Taylor style "plate conversions". They are fine , shoot well, existed in the time period, but are not as
asthetically pleasing to me...
The Pale Rider looks like a non-ported thickplate conversion, it looks good, the only downside is having to take the whole shebang out
plate and all to reload.
as always, just my thoughts and opinions, ymmv,
hope this helps
prof marvel