Looks like the Stoeger is the right choice. And you're right, Coffinmaker, I never viewed a pump shotgun as a "cowboy" gun, but it had such a good reputation I figured it was worth asking. Hp246, I don't have the funds to accumulate spare guns right now, so tried and true works for me.
Thanks for your input. I realize this has probably been hashed to death in the past, but everyone seems to have a different opinion. But you both make good points.