Condition determines the value of anything. I just got $1500 for a 26 year old Toyota 4x4 because it was properly maintained.
Shiloh does their best to dissuade people from ordering the .45/110 and .45/120 unless they are seasoned BPCR veterans.
Same for the .50 chamberings larger than 50-70. But - some guys gotta have the biggest gun on the range. I LOVE watching them shoot them, gritting their teeth, pretending they're having a good time after a the first few shots. Usually develops into a world class flinch.
Then I challenge them to a casual match .....
You rarely see Shilohs chambered in 45-70 on the market. They tend to be keepers.