First time I went through Big Timber, I didn't realize that both C.Sharps and Shiloh were on opposite sides of the same street!
I conducted my business at C.Sharps, only noticing Shiloh on my way out of town. I went to Shiloh on my next trip to town.
I've only owned one C.Sharps rifle, a '75 Business rifle in 45-70. Foolishly, I sold it. It had an excellent barrel and shot like a hot damn.
Both makers make fine products. You pays you money - you takes you choice.