While the "nominal" bullet diameter, and allegedly the groove diameter of original Winchesters chambered for .44 WCF (.44-40) was (and the SAAMI standard still is) .427+.000 -.003, many...not all... of the original Winchester M1873's have much larger groove diameters, and most of the ones I have measured were NOT worn. It would appear that Winchester was concerned about excessive BP fouling from rapid fire, and thus enlarged the barrels internally. To compensate for the oversized bore/grooves, they sold the ammo using dead soft lead bullets, which, as w44wcf has demonstrated, appear to work pretty well. I have an original '73 with a .434" groove barrel. I don't shoot BP very much, and I can tell you that smokeless powder behind hard cast .429" bullets will give you "minute-of-foot" groups at 25 yds! The rifle will shoot some smaller groups using jacketed .429" bullets and smokeless because the rifling is deep enough that the jackets will grip the rifling. Of course, that is not only hard on the rifle, but can't be used in CAS matches. I don't use it for matches, relying on modern-made rifles. Just thought you'd like to know.