I am in full agreement with Pettifogger. I also agree with everyone else. So, as you can see, I am of TWO minds (Don't bring me int this)
"If" you reload, or if your going to reload, going for 44 Special, Russian, Colt chambering allows the use of more historically correct ammunition. Yea!!!! Except, this is a fantasy game we play, to be played at each shooter's level. I personally opted for Open Tops in
44 because I could play with guns that approximated yesteryear. HOWEVER. Being a gunsmith, reloader and shooter made it really easy.
For a neophyte (y'all didn't think I knew that wurd didja), taking that route is financial suicide. You cannot walk into the local Wally World,
or your local gun shop, nor your big box sporting good store and expect to find 44 Colt nor 44 Russian. You will have to order it, and when it comes in, you will need to have your BROKER in your hip pocket.
As pointed out by Pettifogger, you can get 38 Special ANYWHERE and at a reasonable cost. Let your wallet be your guide.
Coffinmaker