What ever product you settle on, remember one thing 10% of what you think it needs will be close to right for most peoples idea of loving care. It seems that most people follow either one of two extremes no care at all or way overboard on care. Of the two, no care will give a longer life unless the leather is exposed to extreme conditions. As to products, I was actually using Ballistol on the last holsters I used and though I would not recommend it, it seemed to perform well for the several years I tried it??? I repeat, I think that the amount used is far more important than the brand name.