I remember reading that post when it was first made. Lots of great pictures, and a great report. My '73 is chambered for .44-40, and had a lot of trouble cycling ammo when I first got it. Marstar sent me a new bolt, and it solved the problem. That being said the bolt (both of them) was missing the cartridge rim support on the bottom of the bolt. All primer hits are off centre as a result. It was like they decided not to include it when they made the parts. There is an opening for it below the chamber, and I will get a gunsmith to take care of this omission for me.
While the rifle is accurate, and the action is quite smooth I have had my doubts in regard to recommending this line to other shooters. Uberti's are just to well made. I have seen quite a difference between my Chapparal '73, and my Uberti Henry. Pettifogger is correct in saying that there are better rifles out there. If you don't mind doing some work, and spending some extra cash (providing parts are readily available) the Chapparal would be alright. Marstar has parts, but you would have to call first, and hope they have stock (?).
I like mine... but it took some work to get her where I wanted her, and she still needs work. She is a back up rifle right now. I will not be able to replace her for quite a while, as I need to buy guns for my misses, as she wants to get into Cowboy Action Shooting (whoopee!). I don't mind the wait considering.
Swede