I am as objective as possible. If you think Colt is wonderful, then enjoy them. Just don't get your drawers bunched up if someone says USFA's are better ON THE USFA FORUM. Cry "bunk" all you want, maybe it's YOU who can't be objective. There is a VERY good reason why Colt has vastly improved their guns in the last couple years and that reason, is USFA. If Colt's were "all that", then why would they have felt the need to improve their product? I'm not talking about the occasional lemon. I'm talking about a SAA that Colt does not even recommend you shoot. I'm talking about terrible over-polishing, dished-out screw holes, rolled-over edges, wallered out lettering, gritty actions, generous dimensions, etc., etc,. Most 3rd generation Colt SAA's look like they've been polished by an angry 700lb gorilla. Not to even mention the stupidly polished white-sided hammers. You know, all those things you Colt guys seem to overlook. All those things that are not an issue with USFA. Nor is an action job even required. You know, those things that cause our nation's premier gunsmith to say that most 3rd generation Colt's are too far gone to save, yet little can be done to improve a USFA.
As far as 175yrs goes, yes, that's exactly what I expect from Colt true-believers. Colt has been riding on military contracts for years now. Has not given a rat's posterior for the quality of their SAA's for most of 3rd generation production. 175yrs means nothing if their last 40yrs has been spotty at best. And for the record, I've spent a hell of a lot of money on Colt sixguns, replicas of Colt's and books on Colt's. The difference is that this has not blinded me to reality. That reality is that USFA builds a better SAA than Colt has in a very long time.
Funny how it's okay to say all day long that Colt's and USFA's are better than Italian replicas but the minute you suggest USFA's are better than Colt's, Colt fans come out of the woodwork. Do you guys not expect us USFA fans to defend our choices the same as you??? The difference being that most USFA fans were never satisfied with Colt's but most Colt true-believers never looked at a USFA with an open mind. If you don't want to hear this, go play on the Colt forum.