Howdy Dispatch, You've created an interesting thread here. A couple of guys I regularly shoot with have Kirkpatrick rigs, and they seem to be well made, and in my observation, very commerical looking. Someone on this thread used the term "Off the shelf" and I think that's a fair comment. That's not a dig, just a fact.
It all depends on what you want, long term. I'll gave you an analogy concerning a knife. I've been looking at knifes for my CAS rig. There are loads of commerical knifes available, in a wide range of quality and prices. I've chosen to have a knife custom made for me by one of our Forum members, Ned Buckshot. I could get one quicker and for less money going the commerical route, but I think it's a cool thing to be able to say "I had this one made for me by a custom knife maker"
I'm building my own holsters & belts now, and they are nowhere near the quality of some of the guys on this Forum, who do incredible work. However, when people ask where I bought my leather, it's great to be able to say "I made this myself" The next best thing, at least for me, would be to say "I had this custom made for me by" and I would choose one of the Craftsman on this Forum to makle one for me.
And I'll tell you, the decision as to which one would be extremely difficult, because there are so many Pards here that do really great work. Another thing about working with a Craftsman from this Forum is you can dialog about exactly what you want, and have one truly custom made.
No disrespect to the big name builders, they got where they are because they did and still do quality work. Some guys I shoot with want the big names, and that's OK. Their money, their choice.
So the question remains, what do YOU want? Respectively, JD