There used to be another guy in Huntsville who made some incredible badges and belt buckles for many of my fellow LEO's, but unfortunately he got himself killed in a bar fight three months after parole; Mike Sellers was his name. Used to be able to get leather products, badges, buckles, etc., from the TDC craftshop but some folks ruined it for everyone. I think you can still order a replica badge from TDC as long as the request is sent on your department's letterhead, signed by the chief. Inmate Braden Howard is a lifer but did some work for me which rivaled Sellers, but I don't know which unit he's at.
Starpacker badges comes to mind as doing quality work, might want to check their website.