I had a charcoal blue fluted Cyl. 1860 Army.
As the finish aged it did wear thin in some places and overall to a most pleasing brown patina.
I liked it
You'll like the Henry, I've owned 3 ( I let one an 1980 model in 44-40 get away ) I still have 2 ( a Mil. Model and a Steel Frame model) both in 45 Colt.
You might have a choice in finish , In the white, Browned, Blued & the Charcoal blue... all mine were Blue.
In all the years mounted reenacting with the 80 Model and shooting the other two, the only issue was a bent magazine spring on the 44-40 and that was my fault.
I hung it up on a branch dismounting.