From 'Colt Cavalry, Artillery and Militia Revolvers' - by Cochran.
"In 1872, the Ordnance Department called for revolvers to be tested for possible adoption for the Cavalry service.
Smith and Wesson sent three revolvers and Colt sent one.
The tests on the Smith and Wesson revolvers were complete in October, and the Colt was not received until November, and was returned, as it was chambered for the .44 Russian cartridge (the S&W's being chambered in .44 American).
Colt installed a cylinder with the same caliber of the Smith and Wessons and returned the revolver; tests were conducted on tis revolver and were completed by December 27, 1872.
These were very complete tests, including firing and rusting.
Ordnance Notes No. V, published in Washington, June 27th, 1873, gives the results of these tests as carried out at the National Armory in Springfield, Massachusetts.
The Colt was unhesitatingly declared the superior revolver "in most respects, and much better adapted to the wants of the Army than the Smith and Wesson."
During these tests, the Government specified that a .45 caliber cartridge would be required.
This was to conform to the .45-70 cartridge adopted for the rifle.
By 1873, Frankford Arsenal was manufacturing cartridges for this new caliber and the Benet method of priming was used.
Subsequent manufactured for the Colt Cavalry Model revolver were of this type and were continued until 1882, when when the outside primed cartridge with the separate anvil was used."
Vaya,
Scouts Out!